In State Budget: Keep Children Safety First

ALBANY, NY (02/02/2010)(readMedia)-- In testimony before the State Senate and Assembly fiscal committees, the New York Association for Pupil Transportation today called for a renewed focus on school bus safety in New York. In a statement before the Senate Finance and Assembly Ways and Means Committees, NYAPT Executive Director, Peter Mannella, said "the association's members recognized that the state's financial situation is dire and that extraordinary measures may be needed to correct that fact." He cautioned that "some measures might save money but might also compromise safety."

Mannella suggested: "In transporting 2.3 million children, we understand that we must find new ways to manage the costs associated with the school bus ride. However, we caution our state leaders to avoid steps that could compromise the safety of the children or that would unnecessarily result in increased burdens on parents and school communities. Rather, we urge a discussion of the various cost areas that affect transportation in order to moderate those costs with no impact on safety."

In terms of specific provisions in the Executive Budget Proposal, NYAPT:

• offered its support for inclusion in the Governor's budget of $400,000 for the School Bus Driver Safety Training Program. The program, which has been in place since 1997, contributes significantly to school bus safety. NYAPT recommended that the Legislature institute new provisions that would make it possible for the State Education Department to expeditiously expend funds on urgently needed training;
• expressed qualified support for proposals related to regional school transportation services. NYAPT urged the Legislature to set relevant evaluative criteria to gauge the results of a regional transportation demonstration program that would be overseen by the Commissioner of Education as well as regional models initiated by local schools;
• expressed qualified support for a 'shared services' proposal included in the Governor's budget that would allow one district to sign onto a contract that another district has entered into with a private operator pursuant to a competitive bid. NYAPT supports the intent of the proposal but recommends it be time-limited, tied to special circumstances and not allowed to continue into a second school year;
• suggested that the state should examine and address the factors that drive up the cost of transportation rather than advance regional systems. Even in a regionally-operated environment, there are factors that nonetheless drive up the cost of transportation. Among the recommendations from NYAPT is adoption of a standard school-year calendar that would limit the number of days on which school buses must be in operation when public schools are otherwise closed;
• called for a review of the transportation costs associated with students with special needs including students in special education programs and students who are classified as homeless under the federal McKinney-Vento Act;
• offered proposals for reducing costly mandates and streamlining paperwork requirements for school transportation.

Mannella noted that: "We are concerned that this small part of local school budgets is getting this kind of attention. In reality, school transportation can be costly. But those costs are derived from the demands placed on school buses by the education system itself. We transport 2.3 million children each day, many with special needs, many with custom transportation needs. There is no way that is going to be inexpensive."

NYAPT is proud of the record of safety that the school transportation industry in New York State has achieved over the years. NYAPT called on the Governor and the Legislature to not take any actions that would compromise or weaken that record. "The safety of our children cannot be bargained away. Transportation costs represent a little more than 5 cents per education dollar spent. Any savings taken from transportation expenses will be felt in the daily lives of our children and their families. We are prepared to make changes but change must be tempered with an awareness of the safety needs of our children."