NEW: Econ Analysis Shows Food Safety Bill Will Cost NY Households Under $28, Debunks Big Food's Numbers
Industry scrubs its estimates from internet after misleading lawmakers on cost; CSPI/Tufts report shows a 96% reduction from industry's cost estimate
ALBANY, NY (11/17/2026) (readMedia)-- Today, researchers from Tufts University and the Center for Science in the Public Interest published an economic analysis, estimating that the Food Safety and Chemical Disclosure Act will cost New York households at most, about $28 upfront, which assumes that companies will pass 100% of costs on to consumers – an unlikely event. Currently awaiting final signature from Governor Hochul, the bill would strengthen food chemical transparency from manufacturers and ban three harmful ingredients amid longstanding federal food safety gaps.
Commissioned by the American Beverage Association (ABA) and written by Policy Navigation Group (PNG), widely reported industry estimates which have since been scrubbed online grossly overstate the cost of this legislation to New York consumers and the food industry. Key findings from the new analysis include:
- Companies already have food safety data: PNG assumed manufacturers would face massive new data collection costs. Under existing federal law, they should already have the scientific evidence behind their GRAS determinations.
- Consumers and industry would share costs: PNG assumed nearly all costs would land on consumers, an assumption that contradicts the economic literature PNG itself cites.
- $4.88 billion to $219 million: Industry's multibillion-dollar estimate shrinks by 96% once its flawed assumptions are corrected, translating to a largely one-time cost of $28 for New York families.
"Big Food's $620-a-year price tag doesn't hold up to the light. Under federal law, companies are required to already have the scientific evidence behind their GRAS determinations, so the idea that disclosing it would cost billions is a hoax. Once you correct the industry's flawed assumptions, this landmark bill costs New York households about $28, one time. That's a small price for the transparency families deserve about what's actually in their food, and for keeping harmful chemicals off store shelves," said CSPI Senior Policy Associate, Meghan Enslow.
Major food companies are currently sneaking harmful chemicals into the nation's food supply without adequate FDA oversight, thanks to a decades-old federal loophole that allows companies to self-certify ingredients as "generally recognized as safe" (GRAS) and without even informing FDA that the substance has been marketed.
Sponsored by Senator Kavanagh and Assemblymember Dr. Kelles, the Food Safety and Chemical Disclosure Act closes this loophole by requiring manufacturers to disclose safety data for chemicals that have bypassed the FDA's formal safety review.
Consumers are increasingly concerned about the FDA's failure to protect consumers from harmful chemicals in supplements and foods. Recent data confirms that more than 70% of American adults are alarmed about chemicals in the food supply, and 5 in 6 want government and businesses to do more on chemical safety and transparency.
BACKGROUND
The Food Safety and Chemical Disclosure Act (S1239F/A1556G): Ends the secrecy of a federal loophole that allows companies to self-designate their ingredients as "generally recognized as safe" or GRAS without adequate FDA oversight. The bill prohibits the use of three harmful additives in foods sold statewide and requires companies to disclose evidence confirming the safety of food chemicals that bypass the FDA's safety review. By mandating transparency requirements for chemical use in foods and eliminating unsafe additives, the bill aims to improve health outcomes and protect New York consumers from health harms like cancer and developmental delays.
Why Food Safety Regulation Is Urgent:
- Dangers in the Nation's Food Supply: Americans are regularly exposed to food chemicals that have been banned in the European Union, Canada, China, and other countries due to known health risks. Additives like Red No. 3, potassium bromate, and propylparaben have been linked to cancer, hormone disruption, and other serious conditions – yet they remain legal and widely used in most U.S. states.
- Federal Inaction: According to a 2024 American Journal of Public Health analysis, the FDA rarely re-evaluates or revokes GRAS status, even as new research raises concerns about the safety of long-approved chemicals. Simultaneously, the FDA's food safety program has been severely weakened by ongoing layoffs and structural reforms, limiting its ability to inspect, regulate, or enforce food safety standards.
- Chronic Disease Risk: Public health experts have warned that continued exposure to toxic food additives could further exacerbate health inequities and drive long-term costs to the healthcare system. The Food Safety and Chemical Disclosure Act offers New York an opportunity to lead in protecting its residents - especially children - from preventable harm.
###






